Guilded Butterflies, Hope Theatre – Review

“The degree of civilisation in a society can be judged by entering its prisons.”
– Fyodor Dostoevsky

gildedbutterflies - resize 1
L-R: Samantha Pain and Francesca McCrohon / Photos © Rebecca Rayne

While women make up a smaller proportion of prison populations worldwide, the comparatively smaller numbers are often used as an excuse by the powers-that-be to invest less money, resources and pastoral care to women’s correctional facilities. Also, in places that have a track record for ignoring or not ‘recognising’ women’s rights generally, this practise can be traced back to the established legal systems. Of course, as a result of this, no effort’s made for the understanding and rehabilitation of women, and the severest sentences are often pursued… Divised by theatre company ‘Tormented Casserole’ and directed by Kathryn Papworth-Smith, Guilded Butterflies looks at two women who are on death row in the United States.

Maggie (Francesca McCrohon) has been in solitary for a while, but the presence of another prisoner (Samantha Pain) in the cell next to her, lifts her spirits. The other prisoner, however, doesn’t say anything for a very long time, so it’s left to Maggie to chat about what’s on her mind. Maggie’s dialogue is always layered – on the surface concerned with external things, but abounding in subtext about her past and present circumstances. Her dialogue also holds the key to her mental health – based on her conditions in incarceration and the events that led to her ‘crime’.

gildedbutterflies2 - resize 2
L-R: Samantha Pain and Francesca McCrohon / Photos © Rebecca Rayne

As well as playing the other prisoner, Pain portrays two other characters who are important to Maggie – her sister Lauren, plus her lawyer. Between them, we get a sense of the bigger picture and how the ‘outside world’ views this congenial, if unassured, young woman. Hearing ‘the truth’, we understand why Maggie – who has been under mental duress for the longest time – would withdraw from ‘reality’ into her ‘bubble’ of positivity.

While the play deals with weighty issues, the play isn’t didactic – choosing instead to let non-verbal communications and ‘half-said’ conversations convey what the respective characters are truly thinking and feeling. Both actors are excellent in their respective parts, but Gilded Butterflies is undoubtedly Maggie’s tale and even knowing ‘what she’s done’, the audience can’t help but feel empathy for her plight…

© Michael Davis 2018

Four-and-a-half stars

Gilded Butterflies runs at Hope Theatre until 24th November.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s